Assignment 8: “Proposal Critique”
Assignment 8: “Proposal Critique”
In this assignment you will be rewriting and critiquing the proposal provided. There are at least six improvements to be made in the document. Your job is to identify the six improvements and then, using track changes, rewrite or fix the error. Also, using the comments tool, give a brief explanation to why it is wrong and why you fixed it the way you did. Note: If your word processing program does not have track changes, you will need to insert comments in brackets using red font at the improvement location.
In your document, you should:
- Identify at least six proposal weaknesses using track changes.
- Include a critique paragraph of at least 150 words at the end of the document.
- Discuss improvements for each of the weaknesses in your critique.
- Ensure both the comments and critique are concise and error-free.
Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:
- Be typed, double spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all sides; references must follow APA or school-specific format. Check with your professor for any additional instructions.
- Include a cover page containing the title of the assignment, the student’s name, the professor’s name, the course title, and the date. The cover page and the reference page are not included in the required page length.
The specific course learning outcomes associated with this assignment are:
- Outline the strengths and opportunities for improvement of all communications.
- Revise draft documents to improve audience comprehension.
- Employ correct Edited Standard Written English (ESWE).
- Prepare proposals for technical products and/or services.
- Use technology and information resources to research issues in technical writing.
- Write clearly and concisely about technical writing using proper writing mechanics.
Grading for this assignment will be based on answer quality, logic/organization of the paper, and language and writing skills, using the following rubric.
Please click here to view the grading rubric.
The assignment will be graded using the following rubric:
|
Points: 100 |
Assignment 8: Proposal Critique |
||||
|
Criteria |
Unacceptable Below 60% F |
Meets Minimum Expectations 60-69% D |
Fair 70-79% C |
Proficient 80-89% B |
Exemplary 90-100% A |
|
1. Identify at least six proposal weaknesses using track changes. Weight: 20% |
Did not submit or incompletely identified at least six proposal weaknesses using track changes. |
Insufficiently identified at least six proposal weaknesses using track changes. |
Partially identified at least six proposal weaknesses using track changes. |
Satisfactorily identified at least six proposal weaknesses using track changes. |
Thoroughly identified at least six proposal weaknesses using track changes. |
|
2. Include a critique paragraph of at least 150 words at the end of the document. Weight: 25% |
Did not submit or incompletely included a critique paragraph of at least 150 words at the end of the document. |
Insufficiently included a critique paragraph of at least 150 words at the end of the document. |
Partially included a critique paragraph of at least 150 words at the end of the document. |
Satisfactorily included a critique paragraph of at least 150 words at the end of the document. |
Thoroughly included a critique paragraph of at least 150 words at the end of the document. |
|
3. Discuss improvements for each of the weaknesses in your critique. Weight: 25% |
Did not submit or incompletely discussed improvements for each of the weaknesses in your critique. |
Insufficiently discussed improvements for each of the weaknesses in your critique. |
Partially discussed improvements for each of the weaknesses in your critique. |
Satisfactorily discussed improvements for each of the weaknesses in your critique. |
Thoroughly discussed improvements for each of the weaknesses in your critique. |
|
4. Ensure both the comments and critique are concise and error-free. Weight: 20% |
Did not submit or incompletely ensured both the comments and critique are concise and error-free. |
Insufficiently ensured both the comments and critique are concise and error-free. |
Partially ensured both the comments and critique are concise and error-free. |
Satisfactorily ensured both the comments and critique are concise and error-free. |
Thoroughly ensured both the comments and critique are concise and error-free. |
|
5. Clarity, writing mechanics, and formatting requirements Weight: 10% |
More than 8 errors present |
7-8 errors present |
5-6 errors present |
3-4 errors present |
0-2 errors present
|
